New Content Daily Sign Up Here


Must Read: True Story of a Deluded Foreign National Trying to Sue His Way to a Hong Kong Employment Visa

August 27th, 2012

Posted by / in Musing, Refusals & Appeals, Visitor Visas / 13 responses


It is a very rare occasion indeed that private court hearings see the light of day and it tickles me pink that Mr Justice Lam allowed his ‘in Chambers’ decision to be published, so it can be read by anyone generally.

In case you’re not too taken with reading legal judgments, this is the plot from an immigration situation that unfolded in Hong Kong in February of this year:

1. A US national flies from Sydney to Hong Kong en route to London.

2. After touching down in Hong Kong he changed his mind and decided he wanted to fly to Paris instead.

3. The airline wanted more money for the route change, and the man didn’t want to pay.

4. In light of this he passed through immigration at CLK as a visitor and determined he was now ‘stranded’, and reckoned he was incapable of feeding and accomodating himself.

5. He then emailed the Chief Executive, the Secretary for Justice and the Hong Kong Immigration Department claiming he was being held in Hong Kong against his will by the denial of his right to take up employment as a visitor as he wanted to work to obtain shelter and food.

6. It was, he contended, impossible for him to be a ‘visitor’ in these circumstances as he couldn’t leave and his treatment amount to ‘torture’ and thus a breach of the Torture Convention.

7. His legal claim was that he should be given permission to work in order to support himself.

8. The HKID wrote to him and told he needed to make an application for an employment visa  under the terms of the General Employment Policy (just like everyone else).

9. In the meantime, he sought the Court’s intervention to judicially review the decisions leading to his predicament, but didn’t want to pay the (modest)fees for this and demanded (and received) an urgent hearing in the judge’s chambers to try to present his case.

10. The judge kicked him into touch post haste!.

You couldn’t make this stuff up!

You can read the complete 2 page judgement here.


More ‘Related’ Immigration Stuff 

STOP PRESS!! Hitler’s HKSAR passport application has been refused

The Hong Kong Visa Handbook – now available in good book stores everywhere!

Hong Kong employment visa – when all else failed we appealed to the Chief Executive – and won!


Please select the social network you want to share this page with:

The Hong Kong Visa Geeza (a.k.a Stephen Barnes) is a co-founder of the Hong Kong Visa Centre and author of the Hong Kong Visa Handbook. A law graduate of the London School of Economics, Stephen has been practicing Hong Kong immigration since 1993 and is widely acknowledged as the leading authority on business immigration matters here for the last 24 years.



CommentLuv badge